This week, I kept researching, and started filling out the template for the research. I mainly researched about the relationship between colors and meaning and how a same color can be used in different ways to embody a different meaning.
Meanwhile, in class, we started looking at what a literary review is and how to structure it. From what I understood, a literary review explains the research that was done for the paper and in what way that research helped to respond to the research question. It basically is a summary of what the paper will tackle.
This week I continued with the research, so far I have mainly been focusing on how visual storytelling and production design can communicate meaning and feeling through environments. For instance, how lighting and color establish mood and tone, or how production design has a big role in establishing the atmosphere or the character’s mood and personality. One of my sources, Production Design: Architects of the screen by Jane Barnwell even briefly mentions the use of color in the environment of Edward Scissorhands, one of the films I will talk about in the research paper.
“The psychological effects of colour can be harnessed in film design to suggest mood, plot developments and character. Key colours can be attributed to people or places. Edward Scissorhands (1990), for example, gave us a sugared-almond, pastel world of conformity and surface in contrast to the dramatic black environs that the key character had come from. Colour can thus be used as an organising principle behind the design.” pp.63-64, Production Design: Architects of the screen
I am getting more and more interested in how filmmakers use visual design to establish expectations about a place, and then subvert them my revealing a contrast between its appearance and its true nature. Also, thinking especially about Edward Scissorhands, but also Coraline, this relates to ideas of normality and monstrosity (or otherness), or what is safe and dangerous, what is good and bad.
This week I mainly did research, I found a couple books that I am borrowing from the library this week and one online book about production design, essentially it makes the point that the design (colors, lighting, shapes, props, etc) heavily contributes to the tone and mood of a film. I also found a few articles about aesthetics and visual communication in animation that mention how lighting for example has a psychological effect or how colors carry emotional weight.
Basically I think I will start the paper by talking about how environments in film communicate meaning/emotion and then proceed by talking about how in some films those norms can be used to challenge the audience’s perception of the characters and general morality (goodness/evil) of the scene or environment.
An environment that appears beautiful can be dangerous = Coraline & Edward Scissorhands
An environment that appears monstrous can be innocent and safe = Edward Scissorhands
How can environment design challenge our perception of what is safe versus dangerous?
How can visual appearances shape the understanding of a character?
How can the design of environments challenge the expectations and assumptions of an audience?
For the research paper, I started thinking about what I am interested in, in general, not only in research topics, by making a mind map of my interests.
After this, it was clear that my research for this paper should be about environments, and more specifically how these environments help telling a story, emphasize certain themes or emotions. That is when Matt Early introduced me to the trope of Pathetic Fallacy, which is when environments express human emotions.
Doing some light research, especially about movies that came to my mind when I thought of interesting environments in terms of colors and lighting, I realized that sometimes that trope is used and subverted so that the audience’s expectations are destabilized. Some examples of this are the movie Corpse Bride, Edward Scissorhands and Coraline.
In Coraline, the Other World appears more attractive than the real world, because it is brighter and more colorful, but it actually conceals its sinister nature.
In Edward Scissorhands, the darkness of his castle feels more compassionate, more real, than the bright, pastel-colored suburb.
Finally, in Corpse Bride, world of the living feels gloomy, the color plaette is almost uniquely made of shades of grey, while the world of the dead feels much more alive.
The main question of my research at this point is: how does visual design in animated films subvert the audience’s expectations of a character or environment?
I have only just now started a more academic based research, with only a couple sources so far about for instance the psychological effect lighting has in movies. I do not know yet if I will have enough sources,we will see very soon I guess.
The scene starts with the Witch dipping an apple in a seething green concoction. When she pulls the apple out of her cauldron, it has turned black, and is covered still with the slimy green liquid that takes on the shape of a skull as it drips down. The close-up shot makes it so that the apple is the center of our attention and the color of the liquid, a faded blueish green, evokes the idea of poison. The green is also radiating from the apple, which makes the fruit stand out even more, but also emphasizes its toxicity. Furthermore the skull imagery makes it clear that the apple has become lethal.
In this second shot, we have once again a close-up, and two elements are important here: the apple and the crow. The apple, that has now turned into an almost unnatural bright red, symbol of danger, is held by the Witch’s hand. Her long, bony fingers and her sharp nails make her hand look frightening as it evokes death and decay. The body language of the crow, often also viewed as a symbol of death, makes it appear scared of the apple. The room is dimly lit, with a lot of shadows, the color black takes on half of the shot, present through the feathers of the crow, the cloak of the Witch and the shadows. This creates a dark, mysterious atmosphere that emphasizes the sinister nature to the scene.
We have here a medium shot that shows us a bit more the location in which the scene takes place. Once again, the colors are muted, except for the red apple, still in the center of the story at this point. The sinister atmosphere remains, and behind the Witch, we can even see a skull. Each shot seems to indeed contain at least one symbol of death. In the foreground and center of the shot is the Witch, cloaked in black, with the appearance of an old woman. Her wrinkled and harsh facial features, her frowned eyebrows and her open mouth, showing one single tooth, make her look particularly menacing. Her left hand is raised, bringing one more time attention to her fingers, that look more like claws. On the wall behind her, her shadow seems almost bigger than her, making her look intimidating and threatening.
The first shot we see outside of the Witch’s laboratory. Here we have a medium shot with Snow White at its center. What is particularly interesting here is that the viewer knows there is a threat without seeing it directly. The shadow of the Witch in fact fills the scene, bringing darkness to the otherwise well-lit room. Following the change in light and atmosphere all the characters turn their heads and appear terrified with their wide eyes and open mouths.
The next shot shows us what the characters were so afraid of – understandably so, this is probably the scariest the Witch has ever looked. This medium shot shows us the Witch standing in front of the window, on the other side of which Snow White is baking a pie. Her body language makes her appear very frightening: her hunched posture, asymmetrical face, piercing eyes, with one eye more open than the other, and her pointy nose covering her mouth all contribute to how disturbing she looks. But more importantly, her stance in front of the window emphasizes the threat she poses to Snow White. She is imposing her figure by obstructing the view of the beautiful landscape. The window, a representation of freedom and escape is blocked by the Witch who now seems to be trapping Snow White inside. Furthermore, she is almost climbing through the windows, both her hands are resting on the windowsill and she seems like she about to enter the house.
The following medium shot reveals the contrast between the Witch and Snow White. The Witch is hunched over, crooked, and wears a black cloak with its hood pulled over her head, in an attempt to conceal herself. Her dark clothing, paired with her very pale skin, associates her once more to death. Snow White instead has soft features, rosy cheeks, red lips, and colorful clothing, with even a bow in her hair. Her gracious posture and gentle appearance emphasize her kindness even when her space is being invaded by an unwanted presence. The lighting takes on an important role in emphasizing the contrast between the two characters: the Witch is illuminated by the light while her presence obstructs it from reaching Snow White. This makes the Witch appear powerful, she looks like she is dominating the situation. Finally, the apple is almost at the center of the shot, and stands out because of its color, catching the attention of the eyes of the viewer, this almost foreshadows its important role in the events that are about to unfold.
I also wanted to add the shots of the vultures and little birds because they appear almost as the representation of the subconscious fears and intentions of Snow White and the Witch. The vultures, with their black feathers, pointy beaks, and malicious gaze, resemble the Witch and look very threatening and almost cruel, furthermore they are commonly associated with death and are often used/viewed as a omens of death. The little birds have Snow White’s soft features, and reflect her delicate nature, and their fear of the vultures mirrors her own discomfort and vulnerability in the presence of the Witch. I think it is a very nice representation of the inner states of both characters, especially because these shots are sandwiched between shots where the Witch and Snow White are talking to each other.
Are there films you consider break the traditional narrative rules? How is the structure disrupted? Does this juxtaposition or reordering compromise narrative conclusion?
I saw Memento, by Christopher Nolan, for the very first time about a month ago and it was the first film that I thought of that breaks the structure of a traditional narrative. Because the main character, Leonard, suffers from short term memory loss, and the whole plot revolves around this issue, the film’s structure is broken into two narrative sequences, where the main one unravels in reverse chronological order.
The classic story arc is disrupted and even the monomyth (or hero’s journey) seems to be completely disorganized. The film begins as the journey has already started, rather than at a conventional starting point, but, more importantly, I do not think that the concept of beginning and end truly exist or matter in this movie. Leonard’s call to adventure, if we can call it that, is the fact that he believes his wife was murdered and that he must find her killer and get revenge. However, that is a construction of his own mind, furthermore, he will never find satisfaction in the realisation of this purpose, because that very same purpose is the only reason that keeps him going, therefore he will continue to shape the information he collects to respond to his one true quest: never achieving a resolution, never leaving the world of chaos.
Leonard is truly trapped in a descent into the special world with no bottom. If we keep in mind Dan Harmon’s story circle, the protagonist never leaves the unfamiliar situation and therefore never goes through a transformation. The more he forgets, the further away he gets from reality.
Furthermore, the story’s non linear narrative allows the audience to have an experience as similar to the protagonist’s as possible. Just like Leonard, we question events, other characters, and even the protagonist’s own memories. We are continuously forced to reconsider and reconstruct. This is also a very interesting use of editing because it really shows the power it has on telling a story.
It is interesting to think of how stepping out of the conventional way of telling stories affects their conclusion. A satisfactory conclusion, in my opinion, does not always mean a return to normalcy or the resolution of a quest, because life is not like that. Of course stories are not meant to be just like reality, they are a way to escape or explain/simplify life, however, the inspiration for those stories comes just from that: the human experience. A story does not need to provide answers, actually, leaving us with questions can be just as effective.